|
| Girls | College | Year | Boys | College | Year |
| Sadie Yinger | ETSU | 2011 | Justin Newring | King | 2011 |
| Taylor Mays | University of the Cumberlands | 2011 | Will Templeton | Liberty | 2012 |
| Alexis Hewitt | Lee | 2012 | Jonathan Chastain | Carson Newman | 2012 |
| Kyla Pelletier | Principia | 2012 | Daniel Sonnenfeldt | ETSU | 2013 |
| Lindsey Kessler | ETSU/Samford | 2012 | Tim Rupert | King | 2013 |
| Ashley Kessler | ETSU | 2012 | Aaron Templeton | Furman | 2014 |
| Emily Yarnell | Tennessee | 2012 | Lachlan Dickie | Carson Newman | 2014 |
| Hannah Feiten | Lipscomb | 2013 | Chris Thomas | King | 2014 |
| Cassie Smith | Carson Newman | 2013 | Jose Parrilla | Carson Newman/Tennessee | 2015 |
| Jayde Hodge | Carson Newman | 2013 | Dartanian Oakley | Tennessee | 2015 |
| Emma Mashburn | Furman/Miami of Ohio | 2014 | Isaiah Woodruff | Tennessee Wesleyan | 2015 |
| Alexandra Christopoulos | Wofford | 2014 | Weldon Wright | Tennessee | 2015 |
| Karlie Yinger | Tennessee Wesleyan | 2014 | Ben McCay | ETSU | 2015 |
| Abby Ervin | Tennessee Wesleyan | 2014 | Riley Honken | Lee | 2016 |
| Lona Williams | High Point | 2014 | Tanner Witsell | ETSU | 2017 |
| Gabby Fewell | Carson Newman | 2014 | Adan Vazquez | Tennessee Wesleyan | 2017 |
| Liza El-Ajam | Tennessee | 2014 | Kenton Bachmann | Wake Forrest | 2018 |
| Molly Griffin | Tennessee Tech | 2015 | Nolan Brown | King | 2018 |
| Tamia Crockett | Missouri/Tennessee | 2015 | Willington Wright | MTSU / Texas | 2018 |
| Brenna Kusch | Tennessee Wesleyan | 2015 | Alex Freshour | University of the Cumberlands | 2018 |
| Neyasha Honorable | King / ETSU | 2016 | Miguel Parrilla | ETSU | 2019 |
| Reagan Goins | ETSU | 2016 | Ian Salyer | Carson Newman | 2021 |
| Gia Faoro | ETSU | 2017 | Alex Brittain | Milligan | 2021 |
| Symphony Buxton | ETSU | 2017 | Nate Lawson | Carson Newman | 2021 |
| Rebekah Hampton | UTC | 2017 | Luke Anastasio | Windthrop | 2021 |
| Madison Grimm | Arkansas State | 2018 | |||
| Lizzie Davis | Lynchburg College | 2018 | |||
| Kensi Gray | University of South Carolina | 2019 | |||
| Ellie Bachmann | University of Alabama | 2020 | |||
| Dominique Romain | Yale | 2021 |